Vertical Board, Shiplap, Board & Batten, Metal Siding: Which Home Siding Is Best?

The decision to choose the right siding for your home can be overwhelming. Each type offers its own set of advantages and drawbacks. At Rustic Door and Pine, we understand the importance of selecting the perfect siding to match your aesthetic preferences, budget, and maintenance needs. 

We love the look and resiliency of cedar and pine board and batten. Board and Batten interiors have an incredible, traditional look, and the exterior uses of cedar and appropriately prepped and sealed pine for the vertical board and batten siding is a stunning finish for any home or Central Pennylvania cabin. But what about metal siding? Which is best? In this blog, we’ll compare vertical board and batten siding to other popular types of siding, such as metal, to help you make an informed decision.

The Many Types of Home Exterior Siding

Board and Batten

Board and batten is a siding style that consists of wide vertical boards (the "boards") with narrower strips (the "battens") covering the seams between the boards. This method creates a layered, textured look known for its rustic and classic appeal. It is commonly used in exterior and interior applications and is especially popular in country and farmhouse-style architecture especially in cedar and pine woods. 

Vertical Board

A vertical board refers to a type of siding or paneling in which the boards are installed vertically rather than horizontally. This installation method can enhance the height and linearity of a structure, providing a distinctive and often more traditional appearance. Vertical boards can be used in various styles, including board and batten and tongue-and-groove paneling. Wooden paneling is a popular material. 

Shiplap

Shiplap is a wooden board commonly used as exterior siding in constructing residences, barns, sheds, and outbuildings. The boards are usually installed horizontally and have a groove cut into their edges, allowing them to overlap and fit tightly together. This overlap creates a weatherproof seal and gives a distinctive shadow line between each board. Shiplap has gained popularity in interior design for its clean, modern look with a hint of rustic charm.

Siding

Siding refers to the material used to cover the exterior of a building to protect it from the elements. It serves functional and aesthetic purposes, shielding the structure from weather damage while enhancing its visual appeal. Siding can be made from various materials, including wood, vinyl, metal, fiber cement, and composite materials. Each type of siding has advantages and characteristics, influencing factors like durability, maintenance, and cost.

Metal Siding

Metal siding is exterior cladding made from metal, such as aluminum or steel. It is known for its durability, low maintenance, and resistance to fire, pests, and rot. Metal siding can be designed to mimic other materials like wood or stone or feature a sleek, modern appearance. It is often used in residential and commercial buildings and is appreciated for its long-lasting performance and minimal upkeep requirements.

Pros of Wooden Siding

Aesthetic Appeal

Classic and Rustic: Vertical board-and-batten siding offers a classic, rustic look that can enhance the architectural beauty of both modern and traditional homes.

Versatility: It can be painted or stained in various colors to match any home design.

Durability

Strong and Resilient: When made from high-quality lumber like cedar or pressure-treated and sealed pine, this type of siding is resistant to decay and insect damage.

Weather Resistance: Properly installed and maintained, board and batten siding can withstand harsh weather conditions.

Ease of Installation

DIY-Friendly: Many DIY enthusiasts find vertical board-and-batten siding easier to install than other siding options, thanks to its straightforward design and large panels.

Maintenance

Simple Repairs: Individual boards or battens can be replaced without redoing the entire siding, making repairs more manageable.

Cons of Wooden Siding

Initial Cost

Higher Upfront Expense: High-quality lumber, such as cedar or redwood, can be more expensive than other siding materials. However, the investment can pay off in durability and aesthetic appeal.

Maintenance Requirements

Regular Maintenance Needed: Board-and-batten siding requires regular painting or staining to keep it looking its best and protect it from the elements.

Pros of Metal Siding

Durability

Long-Lasting: Metal siding is highly durable and can last decades without significant wear and tear.

Pest Resistant: Unlike wood, metal is not susceptible to termite damage or other pests.

Low Maintenance

Minimal Upkeep: Metal siding requires little maintenance beyond occasional cleaning, as it does not need to be painted or stained.

Fire Resistance

Safety: Metal siding is non-combustible, offering added protection against fire hazards.

Eco-Friendly

Recyclable: Metal siding is often made from recycled materials and can be recycled again at the end of its life, making it an environmentally friendly option.

Cons of Metal Siding

Aesthetic Limitations

Industrial Look: Metal siding often has a more industrial appearance, which may only suit some architectural styles or homeowner preferences.

Color Options: While various colors are available, metal siding lacks wood’s natural warmth and texture.

Installation Complexity

Professional Installation Required: Installing metal siding typically requires professional expertise, which can add to the overall cost.

Potential for Dents and Scratches

Susceptibility to Damage: Metal siding can be prone to dents and scratches, especially in areas prone to hail or heavy impacts.

Making the Right Choice

Choosing between vertical board-and-batten siding and other types of siding, like metal, depends on your specific needs and preferences. If you prioritize a classic, rustic aesthetic and don’t mind the maintenance, vertical board-and-batten siding is an excellent choice. It adds character and warmth to your home, especially when crafted from high-quality lumber available at Rustic Door and Pine.

At Rustic Door and Pine, we’re here to help you navigate these choices. Our expert team can provide high-quality materials and advice tailored to your project, whether you’re a DIY enthusiast, contractor, builder, or carpenter. Visit us to explore our wide selection of lumber and siding options, and let us help you create the perfect exterior for your home.